28Mar/1140

Blog Watch Edition 8c: Critical Loop

There’s a loopy set of assumptions circulating trough the bloggasfear as of late. Details after the jump.

Great Debates: Lupe Fiasco – Is He An All Time Great, Or A FiascoOmar Burgess and staff writer Slava Kuperstein are fully confident that their collaborative piece provides something of value to the unwashed masses. In the introduction they claim that “one of the worst things about the Internet is the lack of any kind of coherent, civil discourse” but add that any hooligans wishing to wreak havoc on the comments section with ad-hominem attacks should feel free to do so, because such participation generates revenue for the site through page impressions.

That’s kinda funny, but the comments section suggests that the readers were able to politely articulate their valid objections to this piece’s lack of focus and generalization.

The theme of the so-called debate might be Lupe’s popularity, but it isn’t made entirely clear, no terms are defined, and title of the post leads one to believe otherwise anyway. So much for coherence. Even if we can all agree that Lupe’s popularity is a worthy subject of debate (it’s a stretch if we abide by the dictionary definition of debate), the vitality of any debate is threatened when both participants fall in lock-step agreement with each other over the same easily contested dogmatic claims.

In this case Burgess and Kuperstein instantly agree that Lupe Fiasco is “without a doubt, among the two or three most talented emcees to come out since the mid-2000s” and that the rapper at one point possessed “all the things I look for in an emcee: technical precision, personality, storytelling.” The former statement is a general pronouncement while the latter is more of a personal opinion shared by the two debaters, but both are extreme claims that beg to be scrutinized, if only to be logically debunked. Should “civil discourse” be pursued at the expense of gaining a nuanced understanding?

The discussion of the musical content of Lupe’s new album Lasers is brief because both debaters agree on its strengths and weaknesses. That is to say, they both agree that Lupe is a singularly courageous, gifted rapper who can make cerebral political content “palatable and not preachy” but uses “simple cadences” and “lazy metaphors” and chooses to rhyme over production that is “ass.” Say what?

This isn’t civil discourse, this is unilateral cheerleading. The logic of dogma demands that Lupe’s weaknesses and failings are either spun into strengths just or glossed over. Commentary about his new music must not challenge the idea that Lupe is transcendentally great, no matter how the new album sounds.

The reader is expected to tacitly accept that “All Black Everything” and “Words I Never Said” represents the kind of ballsy political statements that few other rappers would dare to attempt. This idea is an outgrowth of another that suggests that rap is largely devoid of social or political consciousness by the way.  This is a fundamentally problematic and flawed argument, one that I have addressed before (( See Blog Watch Edition 7.)) and persists in spite of evidence to the contrary. In this piece it remains unchallenged because it assists the greater project of touting Lupe as exceptional. But plenty of rappers have recently penned politically-oriented lyrics that are more timely and insightful than those found on Lupe’s latest release. ((I discuss one prominent example here; the comments section has lots of other examples.))

If we choose to honestly assess music through informed discourse, then we must also accept the responsibility of revising our opinions as new evidence comes to light. That’s a lot of work to put into a debate in which nothing is contested, so it doesn’t happen here. The authors abandon the topic of musical content before a single point of contention is raised or any claims can be explicated or clarified. They then strike up discussion about every single Lupe Fiasco-related micro-issue that was reported in the blogs over the past year, in no particular order and with no direction.

After a long, convoluted back-and-forth about the trivial issue of whether or not Lupe’s private behavior neatly parallels his public persona, Burgess and Kuperstein arrive at a conclusion that isn’t conclusive or even exciting: “Lupe and Atlantic managed to pull off the great compromise. Die-hard Lupe Fiasco fans purchased this album, and the commercial success of “The Show Goes On” generated enough crossover success to bring in some new fans.” What was being debated, why was it once considered important, and how did we end up here?

Bonus – Witness the middling ideology of Lupe Fiasco exceptionalism creep into online reviews of Lasers.

Tags: , ,

---------------------------------------------------------------

49 Responses to “Blog Watch Edition 8c: Critical Loop”

  1. EihtHype says:

    why the fuck is this on this blog? Analysis of articles from other websites about contemporary rappers. How about we juts discuss the finer points of Lil Wayne and Kid Cudi and be done with it…

    • Thun says:

      It is my opinion that a discussion of contemporary rap is vital to appreciating and understanding hip hop’s past. The Blog Watch series is intended to spotlight fallacious reasoning (much of which can be attributed to a poor understanding of hip hop’s past) and to educate those readers who do follow the current scene about critical discernment. In the case of Lupe Fiasco, he is consistently held up as en exemplar of talent and virtue, as well as a torchbearer for hip hop’s past, so I think it is important for fans of older rap music to assess his music and the claims surrounding it.

      Whether you like it or not, the hip hop of the past is not relegated to a sealed mylar pouch on a shelf in some collector’s mother’s basement. It lives and breathes in a contemporary context, too, so I’ll continue to write about pertinent discussions. I don’t write anything for this blog with the expectation or wish that everybody agrees with it.

  2. Victor says:

    Excellent analysis Thun, though to some degree I can understand the nature of articles/reviews regarding lupe in the last year or so. Objectivity, due to the nature of dude’s erratic character are difficult. I know this as if i was to write a review it would be full of a combination of the issues outlined above! Lasers was such a pile of crap that it was going to exacerbate the divisive nature of lupe anyway. Dude is a talented emcee, but the internet has helped promote this idea that we (whoever we are) need a saviour kind of emcee who tackles “political” issues but isnt “preachy” like kweli as if there arent a swathe of emcees that fill different lanes.

    This blog watch series is very good, i just wish some of these writers responded.

    • Thun says:

      Yeah I’m not surprised that coverage of Lupe involves a whole lot of speculation about matters removed from the content of his music, or that discussions about his music inevitably get tangled up with such frivolous concerns. I just wish the coverage was more balanced, and more critical where it counts.

      I agree that the internet has helped promulgate the notion of hip hop being sick and in need of immediate assistance in the form of a “conscious” emcee in the narrowest sense. It is one of the most annoying and unnecessarily divisive ideas out there. How in the hell does hip hop, of all popular music genres, want for social commentary?

  3. yopute momde says:

    lo2c51 Thanks again for the article post.Much thanks again. Really Great.

  4. There is noticeably big money to comprehend this. I assume you have made certain nice points in features also.

  5. It as nearly impossible to find experienced people about this topic, but you sound like you know what you are talking about! Thanks

  6. Now, there are hundreds of programs available ranging from free

  7. Wow! This could be one particular of the most useful blogs We have ever arrive across on this subject. Basically Fantastic. I am also an expert in this topic therefore I can understand your effort.

  8. I simply could not go away your web site prior to suggesting that I extremely loved the standard information an individual provide for your guests? Is gonna be again regularly to check out new posts.

  9. Fitness blog says:

    Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic blog.Thanks Again.

  10. nike air max sale It is actually fully understood that she can be looking at a great offer you with the British team.

  11. magnificent issues altogether, you simply gained a new reader. What would you recommend about your put up that you simply made some days ago? Any certain?

  12. very own blog and would love to learn where you got this from or exactly what

  13. rc modely says:

    The Birch of the Shadow I think there may possibly be a number of duplicates, but an exceedingly useful list! I have tweeted this. Lots of thanks for sharing!

  14. wow, awesome post.Much thanks again. Really Great.

  15. Your explanation is the best I have seen so far

  16. dispensary says:

    This unique blog is obviously interesting as well as informative. I have chosen a lot of helpful things out of this source. I ad love to go back every once in a while. Thanks a bunch!

  17. Wow, great article post.Thanks Again. Want more.

  18. Keep up the wonderful work , I read few blog posts on this web site and I think that your blog is very interesting and holds circles of excellent info.

  19. Thanks again for the blog.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.

  20. This is really interesting, You are a very skilled blogger. I have joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your excellent post. Also, I ave shared your site in my social networks!

  21. This blog was how do you say it? Relevant!! Finally I have found something that helped me. Cheers!

  22. Pretty! This was an extremely wonderful post. Thanks for supplying these details.

  23. This very blog is no doubt interesting and besides diverting. I have found many interesting stuff out of it. I ad love to visit it again and again. Thanks a bunch!

  24. Health Blog says:

    Usually I do not read article on blogs, however I wish to say that this write-up very pressured me to try and do so! Your writing style has been amazed me. Thank you, quite great article.

  25. Mudra Yojana says:

    Muchos Gracias for your article post.Thanks Again. Cool.

  26. hilti says:

    Really appreciate you sharing this article post.Much thanks again. Much obliged.

  27. very nice post, i actually love this web site, carry on it

  28. discount says:

    Thanks for the article.Really thank you! Want more.

  29. wow, awesome blog.Much thanks again. Want more.

  30. Wonderful blog! I found it while searching on Yahoo

  31. obat jengger ayam kelamin

    Hallo i particularly like about the picture / article / presentation that you describe. Very unique, interesting and useful. denature Indonesia yaitu sebuah perusahaan yang fokus dalam bidang obat herbal aman dan ampuh tanpa efek samping. obat kami san…

  32. I value the post.Much thanks again. Keep writing.

  33. wow, awesome blog post.Thanks Again. Will read on

  34. Some truly excellent blog posts on this website , regards for contribution.

  35. Way cool! Some extremely valid points! I appreciate you writing this post plus the rest of the website is extremely good.

  36. Very good article.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.

  37. An interesting disсussion is wortһ comment. Ꭲhеre’s no doubt that that you οught to publish more
    about this subject matter, it may not be a taboo matter but
    usually folks don’t ѕpeɑk about these subjects. To the next!

    Вest wishes!!

  38. Pantangan Wasir Berdarah

    sangat bermanfaat bagi saya

  39. Obat Wasir Tradisional Paling Mujarab

    terimakasih untuk infonya

  40. Operasi Kutil Di Kelamin

    terimakasih untuk infonya

  41. Obat Kutil Kelamin Di Bogor

    Really enjoyed this blog.Thanks Again.�Will read on Major thanks for the article.Really thank you!�Because more

  42. obat kutil jenger ayam

    terimakasih masta

  43. obat alami kutil atau mata ikan

    […]I am not positive the place you’re getting your information, but great topic.[…]

  44. Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Perempuan DiKota Banjarmasin

    Pin BB DA4C5F4E.

  45. Obat Khusus Kondiloma Akuminata Di Taiwan

    […]The whole glance of your web site is fantastic, let well as the content![…]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *